Distinguishing between human-generated and AI-generated resumes entails scrutinizing particular traits. AI-written resumes usually exhibit good formatting, lack of typos, and a generalized, considerably imprecise tone. For instance, an AI would possibly create a resume that flawlessly lists expertise however fails to supply particular examples or quantify achievements. A human-written resume, conversely, could include minor inconsistencies however sometimes demonstrates a customized narrative and affords concrete proof of accomplishments.
The flexibility to establish AI-authored resumes is more and more essential in right now’s hiring panorama. It permits recruiters and hiring managers to concentrate on candidates who’ve genuinely invested effort and time in presenting their {qualifications}. This discernment helps guarantee a extra environment friendly recruitment course of and permits for a deeper understanding of applicant suitability past key phrase matching. As automated resume creation instruments change into extra refined, this ability will change into much more essential for efficient candidate analysis.
The next sections will delve deeper into the important thing indicators that may assist distinguish human-crafted resumes from these produced by AI. These indicators embrace analyzing language patterns, assessing the specificity of accomplishments, and evaluating the general tone and coherence of the doc.
1. Generic Phrasing
Generic phrasing serves as a big indicator when assessing whether or not a resume originates from AI. AI language fashions usually depend on widespread templates and business buzzwords, leading to a scarcity of particular element and customized expression. Analyzing phrasing for generality gives precious insights into the doc’s authenticity.
-
Obscure Accomplishments
AI-generated resumes ceaselessly make use of imprecise statements like “improved effectivity” or “streamlined processes” with out quantifiable achievements or context. A human-written resume, conversely, would possibly specify “improved effectivity by 15% by implementing a brand new workflow system.” This distinction reveals the depth and authenticity of the described expertise.
-
Overused Key phrases
Whereas key phrases are important for resume optimization, AI usually overuses them, leading to unnatural and repetitive language. For instance, an AI would possibly overuse phrases like “results-oriented,” “crew participant,” or “dynamic” with out demonstrating these qualities by particular examples. This mechanical repetition could be a telltale signal of AI authorship.
-
Lack of Particular Examples
AI struggles to supply concrete examples that substantiate expertise and accomplishments. Human-written resumes sometimes embrace particular situations demonstrating expertise in motion. For instance, as an alternative of stating “proficient in undertaking administration,” a human-written resume would possibly describe a particular undertaking managed, its challenges, and the constructive outcomes achieved.
-
Generalized Language
AI-generated resumes are inclined to make the most of generalized language that lacks the nuanced vocabulary a human would make use of. As a substitute of utilizing exact motion verbs and detailed descriptions, AI usually depends on bland and generic phrases. This lack of specificity weakens the impression of the resume and raises suspicion concerning its origin.
By fastidiously evaluating these points of phrasing, recruiters can extra successfully discern AI-generated resumes from these crafted by human candidates. Recognizing these patterns permits for a extra targeted evaluation of real {qualifications} and a deeper understanding of candidate suitability.
2. Lack of Quantifiable Outcomes
The absence of quantifiable outcomes usually serves as a robust indicator of AI-generated resumes. Whereas human-written resumes sometimes showcase accomplishments with concrete information and metrics, AI struggles to supply such particular proof. This distinction performs an important function in discerning between human-crafted and AI-produced resumes.
-
Obscure Efficiency Descriptions
AI ceaselessly resorts to imprecise descriptions of efficiency, corresponding to “considerably improved” or “enhanced productiveness,” with out offering measurable information factors. A human-written resume, conversely, would possibly state “elevated gross sales by 20% within the first quarter” or “lowered buyer assist response time by quarter-hour.” This lack of precision in AI-generated content material highlights its incapacity to quantify achievements successfully.
-
Lacking Numerical Knowledge
One of many hallmarks of AI-written resumes is the absence of particular numbers, percentages, or different quantifiable metrics. For instance, as an alternative of stating “managed a finances of $100,000,” an AI would possibly write “managed a considerable finances.” This omission of concrete information weakens the impression of the accomplishments listed and raises suspicion in regards to the authenticity of the expertise.
-
Generic Challenge Outcomes
When describing undertaking outcomes, AI usually makes use of generalized statements like “achieved undertaking targets” or “delivered profitable outcomes.” Human-written resumes, nevertheless, present particular particulars about undertaking outcomes and their impression. For example, a human-written resume would possibly element how a particular undertaking led to value financial savings, elevated income, or improved buyer satisfaction, offering concrete proof of success.
-
Problem in Quantifying Mushy Expertise
Whereas AI can checklist smooth expertise, it struggles to quantify their impression. A human-written resume would possibly describe how robust communication expertise led to the profitable decision of a posh consumer situation, whereas an AI-generated resume would possibly merely checklist “glorious communication expertise” with out offering context or demonstrating their sensible software.
The lack to quantify outcomes successfully reveals a elementary limitation of AI in crafting compelling resumes. This deficiency permits recruiters to distinguish between resumes created by people, who can articulate the worth they carry by concrete examples and measurable achievements, and people generated by AI, which frequently lack the specificity and depth required to showcase real expertise and impression.
3. Overly Good Formatting
Whereas visually interesting, excessively good formatting can typically point out AI authorship in resumes. AI instruments usually adhere strictly to straightforward templates, leading to a flawless presentation that lacks the refined variations and minor inconsistencies typical of human-created paperwork. For instance, an AI-generated resume would possibly exhibit good alignment, constant font sizes, and uniform spacing all through, with none slight deviations. A human-written resume, however, may need minor imperfections, corresponding to barely uneven margins or variations in line spacing. These minor inconsistencies, whereas seemingly insignificant, can paradoxically add to the doc’s authenticity.
The pursuit of flawless formatting by AI can result in a generic and impersonal really feel. Whereas people would possibly prioritize highlighting particular sections or expertise by formatting variations, AI tends to use formatting uniformly. This may end up in a visually interesting however considerably sterile doc. For instance, an AI would possibly use the identical bullet level fashion for each achievement, whereas a human would possibly use bolding or italics to emphasise notably important accomplishments. This distinction in strategy displays the distinct priorities of human writers versus AI algorithms.
Recognizing the potential connection between overly good formatting and AI authorship permits for a extra nuanced analysis of resumes. Whereas visually interesting, flawless presentation shouldn’t be the only criterion for evaluation. Contemplating the general context, together with content material, tone, and particular particulars, stays essential for distinguishing between human-crafted and AI-generated resumes. This understanding permits a extra complete and efficient analysis of candidate {qualifications} past superficial presentation.
4. Absence of Particular Examples
The absence of particular examples in a resume usually serves as a key indicator of AI era. Whereas human-written resumes sometimes present concrete situations to display expertise and expertise, AI struggles to generate these genuine particulars. This distinction proves essential in discerning between human-crafted and AI-produced resumes. Analyzing the dearth of particular examples gives precious perception right into a resume’s origin.
-
Generalized Talent Claims
AI-generated resumes usually checklist expertise with out offering particular examples of their software. For example, claiming “proficiency in information evaluation” with out describing particular initiatives or datasets analyzed suggests a scarcity of real expertise. A human-written resume, conversely, would possibly element how information evaluation expertise had been used to establish developments, enhance decision-making, or remedy a selected enterprise downside. This distinction intimately highlights the excellence between claimed and demonstrated experience.
-
Obscure Descriptions of Obligations
AI usually makes use of generic phrases to explain job obligations, missing the particular particulars that showcase precise contributions. As a substitute of stating “managed social media accounts,” a human-written resume would possibly element particular campaigns managed, engagement metrics achieved, or revolutionary methods carried out. This depth of data gives concrete proof of expertise and impression, one thing AI sometimes struggles to copy.
-
Lack of Quantifiable Achievements
AI-generated resumes usually lack quantifiable achievements that display the impression of 1’s contributions. As a substitute of stating “elevated web site visitors,” a human-written resume would possibly specify “elevated web site visitors by 25% by website positioning optimization.” This skill to quantify achievements gives concrete proof of outcomes and demonstrates a transparent understanding of impression, a attribute usually lacking in AI-generated content material.
-
Lacking Contextual Data
AI struggles to supply the context essential to totally perceive the relevance of listed expertise and experiences. For instance, merely itemizing “undertaking administration” with out describing the particular initiatives managed, the challenges overcome, and the outcomes achieved gives restricted perception into the applicant’s precise capabilities. Human-written resumes sometimes present this context, enriching the narrative and providing a extra full image of the applicant’s {qualifications}.
The absence of particular examples serves as a big pink flag when evaluating resumes for potential AI involvement. This lack of concrete element undermines the credibility of listed expertise and experiences, highlighting the inherent limitations of AI in replicating the nuanced and customized narratives attribute of human-crafted resumes. Recognizing this sample empowers recruiters to successfully distinguish between real {qualifications} and artificially generated content material.
5. Impersonal Tone
An impersonal tone usually distinguishes AI-generated resumes from these written by people. Whereas people sometimes inject persona and particular person voice into their resumes, AI struggles to copy this nuanced human aspect. Analyzing the tone of a resume gives precious perception into its potential origin and the authenticity of its content material.
-
Lack of Private Voice
AI-generated resumes ceaselessly lack the distinct private voice that characterizes human-written paperwork. They have an inclination to depend on generic phrasing and keep away from private anecdotes or distinctive views. This absence of particular person expression may end up in a bland and impersonal tone, making the resume really feel indifferent and fewer partaking. A human-written resume, conversely, would possibly incorporate private experiences or insights that showcase particular person character and keenness.
-
Goal and Indifferent Language
AI tends to make use of goal and indifferent language, focusing solely on presenting info with out conveying enthusiasm or real curiosity. This will create a way of distance between the applicant and the potential employer. Human-written resumes, however, usually categorical enthusiasm for the function and the corporate, making a extra private and interesting connection. For instance, a human would possibly categorical pleasure a few particular undertaking or spotlight a private connection to the corporate’s mission.
-
Absence of Private Pronouns
Whereas not a definitive indicator, the absence or rare use of non-public pronouns like “I” or “me” can typically recommend AI involvement. AI language fashions usually keep away from first-person views, opting as an alternative for a extra goal and indifferent presentation. Human-written resumes naturally incorporate private pronouns when describing experiences and accomplishments, making a extra private and interesting narrative.
-
Uniform and Constant Tone All through
AI-generated resumes usually preserve a uniform and constant tone all through your complete doc, missing the pure variations in tone and emphasis that characterize human writing. People would possibly emphasize sure accomplishments or experiences by modifications in tone or phrase alternative, whereas AI tends to take care of a constant, considerably monotonous tone. This lack of variation could make the resume really feel much less dynamic and fewer partaking.
Recognizing the impersonal tone attribute of AI-generated resumes permits recruiters to extra successfully distinguish between genuine human expression and synthetic constructs. By analyzing the tone, language, and total presentation, hiring managers can establish resumes that genuinely mirror a person’s experiences, expertise, and persona. This discernment contributes to a extra environment friendly and efficient recruitment course of, guaranteeing that real expertise is acknowledged and valued.
6. Key phrase Stuffing
Key phrase stuffing serves as a big indicator when assessing whether or not a resume originates from AI. Whereas strategic key phrase inclusion is important for applicant monitoring methods (ATS), AI usually overuses key phrases to an unnatural and extreme diploma. This overuse creates a jarring studying expertise and alerts potential AI involvement. The excellence between applicable key phrase utilization and key phrase stuffing hinges on context and integration. A human-written resume integrates key phrases organically inside the narrative, guaranteeing a pure movement and readability. Conversely, an AI-generated resume would possibly insert key phrases repetitively and indiscriminately, disrupting the narrative and diminishing readability. For instance, an AI would possibly repeat phrases like “undertaking administration,” “crew management,” or “information evaluation” a number of instances inside a single paragraph, no matter contextual relevance. A human author would weave these key phrases strategically inside the narrative, guaranteeing they improve slightly than detract from the general message.
The detrimental results of key phrase stuffing lengthen past mere readability. Whereas AI would possibly understand key phrase repetition as a power, it might probably set off pink flags for recruiters and hiring managers. Extreme key phrase density could make a resume seem generic and inauthentic, suggesting a scarcity of real expertise and a reliance on automated instruments. For example, a resume saturated with key phrases associated to “software program growth” with out offering concrete examples of initiatives or contributions will doubtless increase suspicion. This synthetic inflation of key phrases finally undermines the resume’s credibility and diminishes its impression. Moreover, refined ATS methods can detect key phrase stuffing and should penalize and even reject such resumes, hindering an applicant’s possibilities of securing an interview. A human author understands the significance of showcasing expertise and experiences by compelling narratives and quantifiable achievements, slightly than counting on key phrase manipulation.
Understanding the implications of key phrase stuffing gives precious insights into the character of AI-generated resumes. Recognizing this sample permits recruiters to distinguish between genuine human-crafted resumes and people produced by AI, finally resulting in a extra environment friendly and efficient analysis of candidate {qualifications}. Transferring past superficial key phrase matching and specializing in real expertise and demonstrable expertise stays essential for profitable recruitment in right now’s more and more automated panorama.
7. Inconsistent Talent Depth
Inconsistent ability depth usually reveals the unreal nature of AI-generated resumes. Whereas human-crafted resumes sometimes mirror a coherent development of expertise and expertise, AI struggles to take care of this consistency. Analyzing variations in ability proficiency gives precious perception right into a resume’s authenticity.
-
Itemizing Superior Expertise with out Basis
AI-generated resumes would possibly checklist superior expertise with out demonstrating the foundational expertise required to realize such proficiency. For instance, claiming experience in machine studying with out mentioning proficiency in prerequisite areas like statistics or programming suggests a scarcity of real understanding. Human-written resumes sometimes display a logical development of ability growth, constructing upon foundational data and expertise.
-
Fluctuating Proficiency Ranges
AI usually reveals inconsistencies in described proficiency ranges for various expertise. A resume would possibly declare “professional” degree proficiency in a single space whereas demonstrating solely primary understanding in a associated discipline. This fluctuation in experience reveals the AI’s incapacity to precisely characterize a coherent ability set. Human-written resumes typically mirror a extra constant degree of proficiency inside associated ability areas, demonstrating a real understanding of the interconnectedness of various competencies.
-
Generic Talent Descriptions with out Depth
AI ceaselessly depends on generic ability descriptions with out delving into particular functions or demonstrating depth of data. For instance, merely itemizing “undertaking administration” with out specifying methodologies, instruments, or undertaking sorts suggests a superficial understanding. Human-written resumes present extra detailed descriptions, showcasing particular experience and expertise in several aspects of undertaking administration. This specificity provides depth and credibility to the offered ability set.
-
Mismatch between Expertise and Expertise
AI-generated resumes can exhibit a mismatch between listed expertise and described work expertise. For instance, claiming in depth expertise in software program growth whereas the work historical past primarily displays roles in advertising or customer support raises a pink flag. Human-written resumes sometimes display a transparent alignment between expertise and expertise, showcasing how expertise had been developed and utilized in sensible settings. This consistency reinforces the authenticity of the offered {qualifications}.
Analyzing inconsistencies in ability depth permits recruiters to distinguish between resumes crafted by people, who possess a coherent and progressive ability set, and people generated by AI, which frequently exhibit inconsistencies and lack depth in ability illustration. This discernment contributes to a more practical analysis of candidate {qualifications} and ensures a extra targeted recruitment course of. By recognizing these patterns, recruiters can establish candidates with real experience and expertise, resulting in extra profitable hiring outcomes.
8. Lacking Private Contact
The absence of a private contact usually serves as a robust indicator of AI-generated resumes. Human-written resumes sometimes mirror particular person persona, distinctive experiences, and real ardour, whereas AI struggles to copy these nuanced human components. This distinction performs an important function in discerning between genuine and artificially constructed resumes. A human-crafted resume would possibly embrace a quick abstract showcasing profession aspirations or highlighting a private connection to the goal firm. An AI-generated resume, conversely, tends to stay to goal information and figures, missing the heat and persona that make a resume stand out. For instance, a person making use of for a job in environmental conservation would possibly point out their volunteer work with a neighborhood conservation group, demonstrating a real dedication to the trigger. An AI would doubtless omit such private particulars, focusing solely on itemizing related expertise and {qualifications}. This absence of non-public contact creates a way of detachment and makes the resume seem generic and fewer memorable.
The sensible significance of recognizing this lacking private contact lies in its skill to reinforce the effectivity and effectiveness of the recruitment course of. By figuring out resumes that lack real human expression, recruiters can focus their consideration on candidates who’ve invested effort and time in presenting themselves authentically. This enables for a deeper understanding of applicant suitability past superficial {qualifications} and key phrase matching. For example, a hiring supervisor reviewing functions for a management place would possibly prioritize candidates who display real ardour and management qualities by private anecdotes or examples of impactful initiatives. An AI-generated resume, even when completely formatted and keyword-optimized, would doubtless fail to convey these essential intangible qualities. This distinction permits hiring managers to establish candidates who not solely possess the mandatory expertise but additionally display the non-public qualities that contribute to a profitable and thriving work setting. Recognizing this sample permits a extra discerning analysis of candidate potential, finally resulting in extra knowledgeable hiring choices.
In conclusion, the absence of a private contact serves as a precious indicator in distinguishing between human-crafted and AI-generated resumes. This understanding empowers recruiters to establish candidates who genuinely join with the function and the group, fostering a extra environment friendly and efficient recruitment course of. As AI know-how continues to evolve, the power to discern genuine human expression from synthetic constructs will change into more and more essential for profitable expertise acquisition. This concentrate on real private qualities, alongside technical expertise and expertise, permits organizations to construct robust groups and domesticate thriving work environments. The flexibility to establish and admire this nuanced human aspect stays a cornerstone of efficient recruitment methods in right now’s dynamic and ever-evolving job market.
9. Restricted Motion Verbs Variation
Restricted motion verb variation usually alerts AI resume era. Human-written resumes sometimes make use of a various vary of motion verbs to showcase accomplishments and experiences dynamically. AI, conversely, tends to depend on a restricted vocabulary, leading to repetitive and predictable language. This distinction gives a precious clue in discerning between human-crafted and AI-produced resumes. For example, an AI-generated resume would possibly overuse verbs like “managed,” “developed,” or “carried out” all through the doc. A human-written resume, however, would possibly make the most of extra particular and impactful verbs like “orchestrated,” “pioneered,” or “streamlined” to explain accomplishments extra vividly. This variation in language displays the nuanced expression attribute of human writing, whereas the repetitive nature of AI-generated content material usually reveals its synthetic origins. The impression of this distinction extends past mere stylistic choice. Using assorted and impactful motion verbs strengthens a resume by showcasing accomplishments extra successfully and conveying a way of dynamism and engagement. Repetitive language, conversely, could make a resume seem generic and fewer compelling.
The sensible significance of recognizing restricted motion verb variation lies in its skill to streamline the resume screening course of. Recruiters and hiring managers can shortly establish potential AI-generated resumes by specializing in this linguistic sample. This enables for a extra environment friendly allocation of sources, directing consideration in the direction of resumes that display real human effort and creativity. Moreover, understanding this connection helps people craft extra compelling and impactful resumes. By consciously incorporating a various vary of motion verbs, people can showcase their accomplishments extra successfully and create a extra partaking narrative. This strategic use of language not solely enhances the resume’s total impression but additionally alerts real human effort and a spotlight to element, setting it aside from AI-generated counterparts. For instance, as an alternative of merely stating “managed a crew of 5,” a person would possibly write “led and mentored a high-performing crew of 5, exceeding all undertaking targets.” This use of extra dynamic and particular verbs paints a extra vivid image of the accomplishment and showcases stronger management qualities.
In abstract, restricted motion verb variation serves as a precious indicator in distinguishing AI-generated resumes from these crafted by people. Recognizing this sample empowers recruiters to streamline the analysis course of and permits people to reinforce the impression of their resumes. This understanding emphasizes the significance of nuanced language and private expression in conveying real expertise and experience, finally contributing to a more practical and insightful expertise acquisition course of. As AI writing instruments change into more and more refined, the power to discern these refined linguistic cues will change into much more essential in navigating the evolving panorama of resume analysis.
Incessantly Requested Questions
This part addresses widespread inquiries concerning the identification of resumes probably generated by synthetic intelligence.
Query 1: How dependable are these indicators in detecting AI-generated resumes?
Whereas no single indicator ensures definitive proof, contemplating these elements collectively gives a robust foundation for evaluation. The extra indicators current, the upper the chance of AI involvement.
Query 2: Can AI-generated resumes bypass applicant monitoring methods (ATS)?
Whereas AI can optimize resumes for ATS key phrases, extreme key phrase stuffing can set off pink flags and even result in rejection. Real expertise and {qualifications} stay essential for ATS success.
Query 3: Do these indicators apply to all AI resume writing instruments?
Whereas the particular output varies throughout completely different AI instruments, these indicators typically apply to the present panorama of AI-generated resume content material. As AI know-how evolves, these indicators could require refinement.
Query 4: Is it moral to make use of AI to generate a resume?
Whereas using AI resume instruments raises moral concerns concerning authenticity and transparency, the moral implications stay a topic of ongoing dialogue and evolving skilled requirements.
Query 5: How can candidates guarantee their resumes stand out in an age of AI-generated content material?
Specializing in showcasing real expertise, quantifiable achievements, and a private contact stays important. Highlighting distinctive contributions and profession narratives helps differentiate human-crafted resumes from AI-generated counterparts.
Query 6: What are the long-term implications of AI in resume writing and recruitment?
The growing prevalence of AI in resume writing necessitates ongoing adaptation in recruitment methods. Specializing in evaluating real expertise and expertise, slightly than solely counting on automated methods, will change into more and more essential for efficient expertise acquisition.
Cautious consideration of those elements gives a framework for navigating the evolving panorama of resume analysis within the context of AI-generated content material. Growing a discerning eye for authenticity and real human expression stays important for efficient expertise acquisition.
The next part will discover additional sources and finest practices for efficient resume analysis in right now’s more and more automated setting. This steerage will empower recruiters and hiring managers to make knowledgeable choices and establish prime expertise.
Suggestions for Figuring out AI-Generated Resumes
The next ideas present sensible steerage for discerning resumes probably created by synthetic intelligence. Cautious consideration to those particulars permits for a extra knowledgeable analysis of candidate {qualifications}.
Tip 1: Scrutinize Quantifiable Achievements: Search for particular metrics and information factors that substantiate accomplishments. Obscure statements like “improved effectivity” ought to increase suspicion. Concrete examples, corresponding to “lowered operational prices by 15%,” point out real expertise.
Tip 2: Analyze Language Patterns: Generic phrasing, overuse of business buzzwords, and a scarcity of customized expression usually characterize AI-generated content material. Genuine resumes sometimes exhibit a extra nuanced and particular person voice.
Tip 3: Assess Talent Depth and Consistency: Consider the logical development of expertise and expertise. Inconsistencies in ability proficiency ranges or claims of superior expertise with out foundational data could point out AI involvement.
Tip 4: Look at Formatting: Whereas visually interesting, excessively good formatting can typically sign AI authorship. Minor inconsistencies and refined variations usually characterize human-created paperwork.
Tip 5: Search Particular Examples: Search for concrete situations demonstrating expertise and expertise in motion. Generic descriptions of obligations with out particular examples recommend a scarcity of real involvement.
Tip 6: Consider Tone: An impersonal and indifferent tone, missing enthusiasm or private voice, can point out AI era. Genuine resumes sometimes convey real curiosity and particular person persona.
Tip 7: Be Cautious of Key phrase Stuffing: Whereas key phrases are important for ATS optimization, extreme and unnatural repetition suggests AI manipulation. Natural key phrase integration inside a pure narrative movement signifies human craftsmanship.
Tip 8: Search for a Private Contact: Real resumes usually embrace private anecdotes, profession aspirations, or distinctive views that mirror particular person character and keenness. AI struggles to copy this human aspect.
By making use of the following pointers, recruiters and hiring managers can extra successfully distinguish between human-crafted resumes and people generated by AI, enabling a extra targeted analysis of real {qualifications} and a deeper understanding of candidate suitability.
The concluding part will summarize key takeaways and provide remaining suggestions for navigating the evolving panorama of resume analysis within the age of synthetic intelligence.
Conclusion
This exploration has offered a framework for evaluating resumes in right now’s evolving job market. Key indicators of AI-generated resumes embrace generic phrasing, a scarcity of quantifiable achievements, overly good formatting, an absence of particular examples, an impersonal tone, key phrase stuffing, inconsistent ability depth, a lacking private contact, and restricted motion verb variation. Cautious consideration to those elements permits recruiters and hiring managers to discern between human-crafted and AI-generated content material, enabling a extra targeted evaluation of real {qualifications}.
As AI know-how continues to advance, the power to tell apart genuine human expression from synthetic constructs will change into more and more essential for efficient expertise acquisition. Prioritizing real expertise, demonstrable expertise, and particular person narratives stays paramount in figuring out top-tier candidates. Cultivating this discernment safeguards the integrity of the hiring course of and ensures the continued recognition of real human expertise.
